by Michael Marder, Executive Director
Sometimes the problem of improving STEM education seems intractable. Experts and everyone else point to dozens of possible fixes to combat declining test scores1: implement more technology, earlier math, different math, more Career and Technical Education certification pathways, and so on.
All of these need to be considered. But one of the greatest problems schools face is easy to define and measure and is often overlooked in the public debate. K–12 schools do not have enough teachers. Schools particularly lack teachers in subjects like STEM that almost everyone agrees students should take.
It is no great mystery where teachers have traditionally come from: college and university educator preparation programs. Unfortunately, between 2011 and 2024 the number of teachers prepared by U.S. universities dropped from 195,000 per year to 129,000 per year (down 34%). The number of STEM teachers dropped from 22,000 per year to below 11,000 per year (down 50%). This resulted in growing STEM teacher shortages starting around 2016. These teacher shortages led to reduced student opportunity, such as a decline after 2016 in the number of U.S. high school students taking calculus.
Shortages have driven searches for ways around this traditional teacher preparation path. One way around it is to allow people to obtain teaching certification from websites after they get a college degree. This results in teachers who teach somewhat less well than those with college preparation, who stay in teaching somewhat less long, and who end up paying somewhat more to teach than they would have otherwise.2 Another way around it is to eliminate the requirement for teachers to have certification. This results in teachers who leave teaching at much higher rates than those who prepared and certified, and it results in students with worse learning outcomes.3 A final way to avoid university-prepared teachers is to have schools without teachers, maybe using technology. This strategy may seem too new for there to be any conclusive information on it at all, but nothing is truly new in education. Decades ago, when I was in eighth and ninth grades, my own school tried doing without teachers, and I got to see firsthand the mixture of benefits and catastrophes that resulted.
Teachers stay in teaching longer and their students learn more when they are certified at universities.
The least expensive way for a person to become a teacher is to do it as part of a four-year bachelor’s degree. This also gives people a faster path into teaching than any other way. The bottom line is simple: Universities provide the cheapest, fastest, and best way to become a teacher.
Getting colleges and universities back to preparing the teachers we need is not impossible. They still have the physical infrastructure, staff, and faculty expertise that allowed them to prepare twice as many STEM teachers a decade ago.
I can suggest five high-impact practices to move us toward this goal. But first, we need to clear up five misconceptions that stand in the way.
Five misconceptions about STEM teaching and STEM teachers
College STEM majors have no interest in teaching. Fact: In survey after survey, most recently in Spring 2026, more than 30% of college STEM majors indicate they would consider teaching as a career.4
Even if STEM majors teach, the conditions are bad and they will not stay. Fact: Consistently, for the last two decades, teachers have said in surveys5 that they were more satisfied with their jobs than those in other STEM occupations. The total compensation package for teachers, when one includes medical and retirement benefits, is competitive with other professions at the same educational level. Half of STEM teachers stay for more than 11 years.6
Teacher education courses spend too much time on educational theory and too little preparing for the real work of teaching. Fact: High-quality programs — and there are many — provide a good balance of practical teaching experience and theoretical understanding, as well as attracting highly capable and committed people to the profession. This is why, when compared with either alternatively certified or uncertified teachers, those prepared in universities stay in teaching longer and their students learn more.
Setting up or rejuvenating STEM teacher preparation programs is prohibitively expensive. Fact: The cost of staff and facilities to prepare teachers is less than the cost for programs such as laboratory science or engineering.7
There are no institutions that have ultimate responsibility for the preparation of teachers. Fact: Colleges and universities, particularly state colleges founded in part or in whole for this purpose, have ultimate responsibility for the preparation and support of high-quality teachers. There is no comparably reliable source of the highest-quality teachers, nor do any alternatives match the geographic reach and scale of the public state university systems.
Five high-impact practices to increase the number of STEM teachers
Recruit college STEM majors to teaching by giving them early teaching experiences. Early teaching experiences give students realistic experiences in schools that are valuable whether or not they ultimately teach and greatly increase the pool of future teachers as students learn whether or not this occupation is right for them.
Target financial assistance to help students who are preparing to teach at the points where they are in greatest financial difficulty. The culminating experiences in teacher certification, including at least a semester of student teaching plus certification exams, can place financial burdens on students that not all are able to absorb. Financial assistance when students need it the most will keep some on the path to teaching who would otherwise leave it.
Keep the time to degree and certification within four years. Students who struggle to pay for college will not be able to become teachers if adding a teaching certificate adds too much to the time and cost of their degree. There is strong evidence of effectiveness for STEM teachers prepared in programs that can be completed alongside a four-year bachelor’s degree8.
Hire experienced secondary STEM teachers to be instructors, mentors, and guides for the next generation. An important feature of university-based teacher preparation is that it provides future teachers close supervision and personal contact with experienced role models for their profession.
Encourage public universities, both internally and externally, to assume responsibility for supplying their communities with teachers, and to elevate the teaching profession. May we find university leaders to set the example and lead this charge. The quality of the public schools depends on it.
The problem of improving K–12 education in general and STEM education in particular seems intractable only so long as we turn away from an obvious part of the solution. The main in-school factor affecting students’ education is the quality of their teachers, and high-quality teachers must come from and be supported by colleges and universities.
The United States built an exceptional network of more than 800 public colleges offering four-year degrees, nearly 200 of which originated as teachers’ colleges,9 distributed throughout every state. They were producing enough teachers for the country as recently as 2016. Solving the STEM teacher shortage, arresting the decline of STEM education, and providing a vibrant domestic STEM workforce is as simple, and as difficult, as convincing the country’s public colleges to recall and embrace their original mission.
_____________
- NAEP Long-Term Trend Assessment Results
- Marder, M. et al. (in press). Math and science outcomes for students of teachers from standard and alternative pathways in Texas. Education Policy Analysis Archives; Rhodes, A. and Marder, M. (2024). Measuring the value of teachers from traditional certification pathways in Texas: A comprehensive study. Education Policy Analysis Archives, 32.
- Marder, M., Torres, L., & Martinez, C. (2024, September 9). Beyond the tipping point: The rise of uncertified teachers in Texas: Report and recommendations from The University of Texas at Austin; Kirksey, J. (2024). Amid rising number of uncertified teachers, previous classroom experience proves vital in Texas. Policy Brief. Texas Tech University; Van Overschelde, J. P. (2022). Value-lost: The hidden cost of teacher misassignment. In Hobbs, L., Porsch, R. (Eds.), Out-of-Field Teaching Across Teaching Disciplines and Contexts. Springer, Singapore.
- Hughes, K., Marder, M., Welch, A, & Adams, W. (2026). Recruiting STEM majors to teaching: A survey of interest in and perceptions of teaching as a career. National Center for STEM Education.
- NORC at the University of Chicago. GSS Data Explorer |. Accessed November 9, 2026.
- National Center for Education Statistics. (2021). National Teacher and Principal Survey/Schools and Staffing Survey (SASS).
- Consider that renovation costs to set up the lab for a single junior faculty member in the sciences can run between $1 million and $ 2 million, which is more than the four-year grants to universities used to establish UTeach STEM teacher preparation programs.
- Backes, B., Goldhaber, D., Cade, W., Sullivan, K., & Dodson, M. (2018). Can UTeach? Assessing the relative effectiveness of STEM teachers. Economics of Education Review, 64,184–98.
- Howard, G., & Weinstein, R. (in press, 2026). "Workhorses of Opportunity": Regional universities increase local social mobility. Journal of Labor Economics.