by Kimberly Hughes, Center Director
The United States faces a growing challenge in preparing enough qualified STEM teachers to meet workforce and educational needs. While demand for STEM talent continues to rise, the number of newly certified STEM teachers has fallen substantially over the past decade.
A new study by the National Center for STEM Education shows that many of the future STEM teachers we need may already be sitting in college STEM classrooms.
Researchers surveyed 764 undergraduate STEM majors at 13 universities across the U.S. to better understand how students view teaching as a career. A common assumption is that STEM students simply are not interested in teaching, but the study found that about one-third of STEM majors who were not already pursuing teacher certification would consider becoming a middle or high school STEM teacher.
The research suggests the challenge is not lack of interest. Many students who are open to teaching never make the transition from interest to action. In other words, a substantial untapped pool of potential STEM teachers is already enrolled in colleges and universities.
STEM Students Value Teaching
The study found that STEM undergraduates generally view teaching positively. Many students described teaching as meaningful work and valued its potential to make a difference in young people's lives. Nearly half said they would be proud to be teachers. Students interested in teaching were particularly motivated by the opportunity to help others, contribute to society, and inspire future generations.
These findings run counter to the narrative that young people do not value teaching as a profession.
Misconceptions Serve as Barriers
If STEM students respect teaching and are open to considering it, why do so few choose the profession? The study reveals that many students have inaccurate perceptions about teaching careers.
Nearly half of respondents believed starting teacher salaries were less than national averages. Many underestimated the value of teacher benefits and retirement systems. Students also tended to be highly pessimistic about teacher retention, with many believing that most teachers leave the profession after only a few years.
When students make career decisions based on inaccurate information, teaching can appear less attractive than it actually is. Better information about compensation, benefits, job security, and career longevity could have a meaningful impact on recruitment.
Teacher Happiness Matters
Perhaps the study's most surprising finding concerns what would make students more likely to pursue teaching. Higher salaries certainly mattered, but they were not the strongest factor. The most important thing was believing that teachers are happy and satisfied in their careers. More students said they would consider teaching if they perceived teachers as fulfilled and supported than if salaries alone increased.
This finding highlights the power of public perception. News stories and social media discussions often emphasize teacher stress, burnout, and frustration. While these challenges are real, the data tell another story: Teachers have historically been and remain more satisfied with their careers than most other occupations.
Encouragement Makes a Difference
The study also found that encouragement from others matters. Students pursuing teacher certification were much more likely to report support from family members, friends, professors, and advisors. Family encouragement was especially influential. At the same time, very few students reported that faculty members actively encouraged teaching as a career option. Many students also said they did not know where to find information about teacher certification.
This represents a missed opportunity. Universities spend considerable effort helping students explore careers in medicine, engineering, research, and industry. Teaching is often overlooked, despite its importance and the strong interest many students express in it.
There Are Practical Obstacles
Interested students can be discouraged by practical barriers. Many respondents indicated they would be more likely to pursue teaching if certification pathways added no additional time or expense to their degree. Extra semesters, additional tuition costs, and complicated certification requirements can discourage students who might otherwise enter the profession. Streamlining pathways into teaching could help more interested STEM majors follow through on their initial interest.
What This Means for the Future
The study offers hope for those dedicated to solving the STEM teacher shortage. Rather than trying to convince entirely new populations to consider teaching, we may achieve greater success by focusing on STEM students who are already interested.
The challenge is helping these students see teaching as an attainable, rewarding, and respected career. Improving awareness of teacher compensation and benefits, highlighting satisfied STEM teachers, reducing certification barriers, and increasing encouragement from faculty and advisors can help convert interest into action. Developing low-stakes opportunities to explore teaching as a potential career can also be key to helping students transition from interest in teaching to engagement in teacher preparation pathways. The future STEM teacher workforce may not need to be invented. It may simply need to be invited.
Subscribe to our newsletter for updates on our work and how to get involved.